天下大事

这个GDP算法进口算负值,一季度因为疯狂进口GDP-4.83%
二世 - 04/30/25 15:58

GDP was negative because of only two components:

- Trade/Imports subtracted 4.83% on tariff frontrunning

- Government subtracted 0.25%, first negative govt "contribution" since 2022

 0    1    90
二世 - 05/01/25 09:26

CHATGPT:

Great! Here's a simple timeline-style breakdown to show how importing goods for inventory can affect GDP across quarters due to timing lags:


Scenario:

A company in the U.S. imports $1 million worth of electronics in Q1, but they are still in transit and only show up in inventory records in Q2. They are not sold until Q3.


Quarter 1 (Q1): Import in Transit

Component Amount GDP Effect
Imports (M) -$1 million Subtracts from GDP
Investment (Inventory) $0 No change yet
Net GDP Impact   - $1 million (temporary dip)

Goods are paid for or logged as imports, but haven't yet increased domestic inventories.


Quarter 2 (Q2): Inventory Arrives

Component Amount GDP Effect
Imports (M) $0 No new imports
Investment (Inventory) +$1 million Adds to GDP
Net GDP Impact   + $1 million (reversal of Q1 dip)

The inventory increase now shows up, correcting the earlier negative.


Quarter 3 (Q3): Goods Sold to Consumers

Component Amount GDP Effect
Consumption (C) +$1.2 million (assume markup) Adds to GDP
Inventory -$1 million Reduces inventory
Net GDP Impact   + $0.2 million (value added)

Only the value added (retail margin, services) contributes to GDP now.


Takeaway:

  • The import itself doesn’t reduce GDP long-term — it’s just a timing issue.

  • The inventory addition and final sale show up in later quarters, restoring or boosting GDP.

  • This is why analysts focus on inventory adjustments when interpreting GDP swings.

Would you like this turned into a chart or diagram?